About The Maker Pasta Shop & Café
The only fresh pasta shop on Martha's Vineyard: handmade pasta, seasonal coastal dishes, and a retail counter selling fresh pasta by the pound. It replaced Little House Cafe in March 2025 and was a James Beard Semifinalist in 2025.
- James Beard Semifinalist 2025
Before you go
Run by chef Carlos Montoya and Sheenagh Caridi. Fresh pasta sold by the pound at the retail counter.
The MV Dining Dispatch
Know before you go.
We follow openings, closings and seasonal hours across all 171 island restaurants. A short letter when there is something to say.